noworldsystem.com

Fed Projects a Four Year Long Recession

Mike Swanson
Wall Street Window
September 24, 2007

Aside from the dollar and long-term bonds all markets went up last week as the Fed demonstrated that it is more fearful of a slowing economy and banking woes than inflation. In fact, it is willing to sacrifice the dollar to save the banks. Just last month, the Fed was saying that the threat of inflation is just as great as the threat of a slowdown in the economy. Now it is cutting rates in a huge way as the DOW is near its all-time high, gold is making new highs, and the price of oil is exploding.

The Fed is obviously terrified. I have noted in the last podcast that Bernanke built his career on a doctoral thesis that claimed that the Fed didn’t cut rates fast enough during the 1929 stock market crash. But if you look at a chart of the Depression bear market with an overlay chart of interest rates you’ll see that the Fed cut interest rates as the market topped. A few years later when the market finally bottomed you’ll see that they had been lowering rates all of the way down.

What Bernanke believes is that the Fed should have cut rates all at once during the start of the bear market instead of gradually over two years. He seems to be putting this belief to work right now. It means that he is gravely concerned about the state of real estate and banking in the United States.

As the NYT reports:

Those wanting to understand the Fed’s reversal can profit from reading two papers by Fed officials which were released this summer as the credit squeeze was worsening.

Taken together they constitute an admission that the Fed was surprised by the housing and borrowing boom on the upside, and now it fears it will be surprised on the downside.

One paper, by Karen E. Dynan, a Fed economist, and Donald L. Kohn, the Fed’s vice chairman, asked why a strong economy had left Americans deeper in debt than ever before.

“The most important factors behind the rise in debt and the associated decline in saving out of current income have probably been the combination of increasing house prices and financial innovation,” they concluded. In other words, Wall Street and rising home prices made it easier to borrow more money, and consumers did so.

That led to more consumption than would have been expected. Now, the authors say, “an unexpected leveling out or decline” in home values could have the opposite effect.

And, Frederic S. Mishkin, a Fed governor, said in the other paper that this leveling or decline could, in turn, have a bigger effect on the economy than the Fed anticipated.

“Although I generally do not place the housing and mortgage markets close to the epicenter of previous cases of financial instability,” he wrote, “I would note that the current situation in the U.S. could prove to be different.”

Mr. Mishkin said he had modified one Fed economic model, concluding that a 20 percent fall in home prices could cause consumer spending to fall by 2 percent within two years, about twice what the old model forecast.

But that was not the point Mr. Mishkin wanted to emphasize. Instead, his model showed that much of that damage could be averted if the Fed acted rapidly to cut rates — as it is now doing.

When Alan Greenspan was at the Fed he often had Fed governors write papers to rationalize and justify changes in Federal Reserve policy. One should read the Mishkin paper mentioned above to understand what the Fed is doing now. If the credit markets don’t revitalize in the next few weeks you can expect to see the Fed lower rates again by another 50 points at their October FOMC meeting no matter where the Dollar, Gold, or the DOW are. They have signaled that they don’t give a damn about the Dollar. All they care about is Wall Street.

One could look at this another way though. One could say that they don’t care about inflation because they see a total bust in housing that will create deflationary pressures in the economy. Mishkin’s paper projects negative GDP growth for the next five years, a Federal Funds rate falling two full points lower, consumer spending shrinking for five years, and the CPI going down and staying negative if housing prices decline by 20%. These negative trends are expected to begin now and accelerate for two and a half years.

He sees such a housing price decline as very likely as house prices fell by 16% from late 1979 through late 1982. Contrary to people who believe that real estate is the best investment you can buy because it never drops, it has dropped in the past. And with bubbles leading to busts it is happening right now. The question remains, when will it stop? When the Nasdaq topped in March of 2000 it didn’t bottom for two full years. Real estate topped out a year ago.

Mishkin isn’t just a normal Fed governor. He is one of Ben Bernanke’s closest friends. The two served at Columbia university together and in 1997 they wrote a book together calling on central banks to make public targets for inflation. Mishkin’s views dovetail with Bernanke’s.

According to Mark Zandi, co-founder of Moody’s Economy.com, housing prices will decline by at least 11% in the next 3 1/2 years. Zandi sees prices in New York city falling from between 1 percent and 7 percent for each of the next five quarters so there is a lot of leeway in his projections. Hey, if we only get an 11% decline and you cut the Fed model projections in half we’re still facing a horrible recession.

Mishkin argues that “the task for a central bank confronting a bubble is not to stop it but rather to respond quickly after it has burst.” Instead of lower ratings as economic conditions deteriorate as his models do, and show practically a depression coming as a result, he advocates cutting rates all at once just as Bernanke’s doctoral thesis about the 1929 stock market crash argues.

What I have to wonder though is what happens if the Fed lowers rates by one percent or more in the next three months and real estate doesn’t rebound? These theories have never been tried before by a Central bank. We don’t know if cutting rates all at once will prevent the damage caused by a bursting bubble. It has never been tested. Even when the tech bubble burst in 2000, Alan Greenspan didn’t lower rates until almost a year later and after the Nasdaq fell to almost half its value.

The problem is real estate is still overvalued just as tech stocks became overvalued in 2000. One would think that real estate will have to drop and return to a normal valuation before it can bottom out, so simply lowering interest rates may not have the wonderful effects that Mishkin and Bernanke hope they will.

What I do know for sure, which is all you need to know to make money, is that they are setting up an inflationary trend. As the Fed prints more money it has to go somewhere. Of course this is bullish for gold and commodities which are now leading the stock market. But it is possible that the DOW and broad market could also continue to go up too.

Related News:

US economy kills American middle class
http://english.pravda.ru/busines….rican_middle_class%20-0

Ron Paul: The Money Has To Come From Somewhere
http://www.house.gov/paul/tst/tst2007/tst092307.htm

IMF: Global Financial Crisis To Be Long Lasting
http://news.independent.co.uk/business/news/article2996170.ece

U.S. Severe poverty rate at highest in three decades
http://thescribblersweb.com/us_severe_poverty_rate_at_highest.htm

Fall-out at the top reveals French finances in freefall
http://news.independent.co.uk/europe/article2996110.ece

Home sales, prices continue to fall
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20970287/

Borrowers told to lie about wages
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/file_on_4/7010415.stm

Northern Rock still lending ‘recklessly’
http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business…cle2512384.ece

Dollar at lifetime low vs euro
http://www.reuters.com/article/hotStocksNews/idUST19472920070924?sp=true

Dollar Falls to Record Low Against Euro as U.S. Growth Falters
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pi…Yk&refer=japan

Taking Cues From Fed, Speculators Bid Up Oil
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/articl….usiness

Premier Says France Bankrupt
http://www.forbes.com/feeds/ap/2007/09/21/ap4144493.html

Israel asks U.S. foreign aid be paid in EUROS
Northern Rock gets 2.9 bln stg
Greenspan Confronted By Activists, Flees From Angry Mob
Greenspan Admits Fed Is Above The Law
Ron Paul Slams Bernanke For Dollar Meltdown
Kissinger Admits Iran Attack Is About Oil
Bernanke panics by ‘launching a nuclear missile into the financial system’
Canadian Dollar at Parity with USD, Bernanke and Saudis Abuse US Dollar
$200 Dollar a Barrel Oil Is Bilderberg Plan To Destroy Middle Class
Oil hits high over $84
Abu Dhabi takes ownership stake in Carlyle Group
Gold hits 28-yr high as dollar touches record lows
Home Price Falls Hit 26% Of U.S. Homeowners
Greenspan: House Prices To Drop Much Lower
Jon Stewart to Alan Greenspan: Why Do We Need the Fed?
Recession Too Mild a Word
Canadian Dollar Trading At Parity With USD
Borse Dubai Gets Stake In Nasdaq
Federal Workers Owe Billions in Unpaid Taxes
UN Global Taxes Before U.S. Senate
Saudi Currency De-Peg To Dollar Inevitable
Inflation fears end rally, sending stocks down
Analyst: Mystery Trades Were Profit Scam For Fearmongers
Dollar hits new low against euro
US expert warns of fresh shocks
Northern Rock: ‘One in 10 chance of property crash’
Congress Asked To Lift Debt Ceiling
Zimbabwe Close To Economic Collapse
Home foreclosures triple in Hawaii
Bank of England doubles emergency loans available to British banks
Fears of dollar collapse as Saudis take fright
China’s Ultimatum: Let Us Invade Taiwan Or We’ll Dump The Dollar
Rogers: Fed Rate Cut Will Trigger Recession
Greenspan Working To Destroy US Economy
Alan Greenspan Defends Himself
Greenspan says euro could replace U.S. dollar as reserve currency of choice
EU Warns China Of Trade Imbalance
Oil hits new high over $82 after Fed rate cut
U.S. gold futures hit 28-year peak
Failed Lender Makes Grab for Employee Funds
Greenspan predicts falling house prices, rising inflation
Greenspan Says China Will Determine World Economic Fate in 2030
Alan Greenspan warns of UK house prices drop
Greenspan alert on US house prices
Credit turmoil set to benefit big banks
Northern Rock: ‘One in 10 chance of property crash’
Hopes of UK interest rate cut ‘before Christmas’ after FTSE rises follow Fed’s swoop to cut rates
Relief as Northern Rock shares up
Treasurys Fall Ahead of Fed Decision
Fed Announces Big Rate Cut
Subprime Fallout: More Companies Slammed
Prepare for prolonged turmoil, says US Treasury Secretary
Oil industry ’sleepwalking into crisis’
Oil Trades Near Record on Speculation of Reduced U.S. Supplies
Mystery Trader To Collect On Financial Meltdown?
Ron Paul Sees Crisis Ahead For Country
Bankers Fear £12bn Run On Rock
Oil Trades Near Record on Speculation of Reduced U.S. Supplies
Oil industry ’sleepwalking into crisis’
U.S. Banks Brace for Storm Surge as Dollar and Credit System Reel
“Business Expert” (?) Ann Coulter: It’s Good for Wall Street to Bomb Iran
Britons Withdraw Billions in Bank Run
Northern Rock besieged by savers
Pound slides, yen up on N. Rock jitters
New saver queues at Northern Rock
E*Trade Cuts Earnings Estimate 25% on Mortgage Losses
Fears Rise Over Online Banking
Stocks may rise on expected interest rate cut
Fears grow for British economy as panic over Northern Rock spreads
World’s banks hit for $30billion in credit crunch
Oil Hits $80 A Barrel For First Time
Senate panel okays $850 billion debt increase
Dollar’s retreat raises fear of collapse
Further signs of US economic pain
British Bank Rocked By Bank Run
Forecast: Housing woes pose risk of recession
Mortgage Lender’s Bankruptcy
US dollar hits record lows
Foreclosures gain on sales
American economy: R.I.P.
US Heads for Recession as Foreign Investors Rush for the Exit from US Dollar Holdings
Dollar Hits 15 Year Low
Gold Rallies Past $700
Greenspan: Turmoil Like 1998
Bad News Puts Political Glare Onto Economy
US economy loses jobs for first time in 4 years
ECB Injects €42.2BN Into Money Markets
Is China quietly dumping US Treasuries?
Markets Brace For Seismic September
Fed Injects 31.25 Billion Into Market
Credit Crisis Has Hallmarks of Classic Bank Run
U.S. at risk of recession from housing
Analysts Dismiss Suspicious “New 9/11? Trades
Credit Crisis Compared To 1930
Bank Warns Emergency Borrowers
Bush Unveils Mortgage Proposals
Congressman: Stock Market Will Eventually Collapse
Comptroller: U.S. Facing Economic Collapse
BIS Warns of Great Depression Dangers from Credit Spree
Market Crash Forecast Suggests New 9/11
U.S. Recession Risk Highest Since 9/11
Economy, credit worries drive Wall St down sharply
Fed Injects 17.25 Billion In Market
Foreclosures Up 93% In One Year
After Foreclosure A Big Tax Bill From The IRS
After Fed’s Rescue, Volatile Days Ahead
Warren Buffett Sees Opportunities In Chaos
Run On The Banks in Los Angeles
Zimbabwe Inflation Rate Hits 7600%
Yields On T-Bills Down Most In 2 Decades
Bruised investors suffer as market continues to swing
The Dow Plunges, FOX Reports Happy Economic News
World Stocks Plummet Yet Again
Economic Expert: We Are Already In An Engineered Recession
China is not the Problem
Heavy losses sweep world markets
Wall Street Pulls Off Late Comeback
Fed Poised To Dump More Money Into Market
Stock Market Brush Fire & Run On The Banks
Food prices rising in double digits
Existing Home Sales Fall In 41 States
Banks Add More Funds To Stabilize Markets
Economic Meltdown Favors The Elite
Central Banks Add Cash To Avert Crisis
Stocks End Mixed After Raucous Week
China dollar attack would be ‘foolhardy’: Bush
Fed Adds $38 Bln in Funds, Most Since September 2001
The “Plunge Protection Team” Working Overtime to Save US Stock Market
China threatens ‘nuclear option’ of dollar sales
World stocks slide on fresh US credit concerns
Dow Plunges 387 On Subprime Fears
Credit Crunch In U.S. Upends Global Markets
American Home to Declare Bankruptcy, Employees Told by Managers
Mad Money Cramer: Bernanke, Wake Up
Wall Street shaken by late-day market surges